Comparing Surface and Subsurface Irrigation Systems for Sports Fields

surface and subsurface irrigation systems for sports fields

In the dynamic world of sports, where every blade of grass tells a story of grit and glory, choosing the right irrigation system is not just a technical decision; it’s about preserving the sanctity of the game. This article is more than a strategic analysis of irrigation systems for natural grass and synthetic turf fields. It’s a tribute to the art of creating perfect playing fields – a blend of playability, safety, and aesthetics. Each irrigation system weaves its magic, ensuring that the fields remain not just grounds of play, but sanctuaries where athletes push their limits, where safety is paramount, and where the sheer beauty of a well-maintained field inspires awe and admiration.

If you are currently planning to invest in a sports turf irrigation or sprinkler system, try our cost calculator to get a customized cost estimate for your needs.

Table of Contents

Natural Grass Fields: Precision and Efficiency

For natural grass fields, the choice often lies between surface and subsurface irrigation systems. Surface systems, like sprinklers, are favored for their ease of installation and adaptability to different field sizes. However, they require careful management to avoid water wastage. Subsurface options, less common in sports fields, offer water efficiency and reduced evaporation but come with higher installation costs and maintenance complexities.

 

Surface Based Sprinkler Systems

 

Among the sprinkler systems, rotary sprinklers stand out for their ability to cover large areas, which is particularly beneficial for expansive sports fields like soccer and football pitches. They ensure that water is distributed uniformly across the field, maintaining consistent moisture levels crucial for turf health.

Pros:

  • Excellent coverage for large areas, ideal for expansive fields.
  • Uniform water distribution, maintaining consistent turf health.
  • Adjustable spray patterns and distances for versatile use.

Cons:

  • Can be less efficient in water use compared to more targeted systems.
  • May not be suitable for small or irregularly shaped areas.
 

Pop-up sprinklers are a popular choice for a variety of sports fields. These sprinklers are installed below ground level and rise up when activated, providing efficient water distribution. They are particularly suitable for maintaining a clean and unobstructed playing surface, as they retract back into the ground after use, minimizing the risk of damage or interference during games.

Pros:

  • Retract into the ground, providing an unobstructed playing surface.
  • Efficient water distribution, suitable for various field sizes.
  • Aesthetic and safety benefits, as they are hidden when not in use.

Cons:

  • Can be more expensive to install and maintain.
  • Vulnerable to damage if not properly retracted.
 

Impact sprinklers, known for their distinctive sound and rotating motion, offer a robust solution for watering. They are capable of covering large areas with adjustable patterns and distances, making them ideal for fields that require versatile watering options. Their durability and ability to operate under varying water pressures make them a reliable choice for many sports facilities.

Pros:

  • Durable and suitable for varying water pressures.
  • Adjustable patterns and distances for flexible use.
  • Effective for large areas with robust irrigation needs.

Cons:

  • Can be noisy, which might be an issue in noise-sensitive areas.
  • The rotating mechanism may require more maintenance.
 

Oscillating sprinklers, another variant, are adept at providing targeted irrigation. They’re especially useful for smaller or uniquely shaped areas, allowing precise control over water distribution. This targeted approach aids in water conservation, ensuring that only the necessary areas receive irrigation and avoiding excessive water usage.

Pros:

  • Provide targeted irrigation, ideal for smaller or unique areas.
  • Help conserve water by focusing irrigation where needed.
  • Suitable for gentle watering, reducing potential turf damage.

Cons:

  • Limited coverage area, not ideal for large fields.
  • May require repositioning for complete field coverage.
Comparison table: Surface Irrigation Systems for Sports Fields
Sprinkler System Coverage Area Flow Rate Pressure Primary Use Application
Pop-up Sprinklers
Moderate to Large
Moderate
30-50 psi
General turf irrigation
Golf, Soccer, Football, Baseball, Rugby
Rotary Sprinklers
Large
High
40-70 psi
Wide area irrigation
Golf, Soccer, Football, Rugby, Cricket
Oscillating Sprinklers
Moderate
Moderate
30-60 psi
Targeted irrigation
Tennis, Baseball Infields, Training Areas
Impact Sprinklers
Large
Moderate to High
40-70 psi
Durable, robust irrigation
Soccer, Football, Rugby, Lacrosse

Subsurface Irrigation Systems

 

Subsurface irrigation systems for natural grass fields, like drip irrigation or in-ground soaker hoses, are focused on delivering water directly to plant roots, which is efficient in minimizing evaporation and runoff. However, they haven’t become popular in sports fields due to several challenges. These systems usually come with higher installation costs because they require extensive groundwork and precise positioning under the soil. Maintenance can be more demanding since issues like blockages or damage are harder to detect and fix when the system is underground.

Another limitation is the lack of flexibility; once installed, making adjustments to accommodate changes in field layout or irrigation needs can be difficult. Additionally, these systems may not provide the even moisture distribution across the turf’s surface that’s crucial for sports fields. Uniform surface watering is key for maintaining the turf quality required for sports, and subsurface systems might fall short in this aspect. Regular turf maintenance practices, such as aeration,

Regular turf maintenance practices, such as aeration, pose a risk of damaging subsurface systems. All these factors combined make subsurface irrigation less viable for sports fields. The need for uniform surface watering, compatibility with maintenance practices, and cost and flexibility concerns lead most sports field managers to prefer surface systems like sprinklers. These surface systems align more closely with the practical and operational demands of maintaining sports fields, especially those designed for high levels of play where turf quality and playability are paramount.

pop up sprinkler for sports fields

Synthetic Turf Fields: Sprinklers for Cooling and Maintenance

Synthetic turf fields require specialized systems for cooling and maintenance, distinct from the irrigation needs of natural grass. Cooling synthetic surfaces, which can get quite hot, especially in direct sunlight, is primarily managed through overhead sprinkler systems. These systems spray a light mist over the turf, significantly reducing the temperature through the cooling effect of water evaporation. This not only makes the playing surface more comfortable but also helps in maintaining the turf’s quality.

In terms of maintenance, synthetic turf requires regular cleaning to ensure hygiene and remove debris. This process often involves the use of brushing systems and vacuums, and sometimes, sprinkling water to settle the infill and clean the surface. An efficient drainage system is crucial in synthetic turf fields, especially when using water for cooling or cleaning. Proper drainage ensures that water used on the field drains away quickly, preventing waterlogging and maintaining the field’s condition. These maintenance measures ensure the synthetic turf remains in top playable condition, offering a safe and hygienic environment for sports activities.

Choosing the Right Sports Field Irrigation System for Your Facility

When deciding on the appropriate irrigation system for a sports field, several critical factors come into play. Each of these elements contributes to determining the most suitable system for specific requirements:

  • Nature of the Sport: Different sports have varying turf needs. For instance, golf requires meticulously maintained turf with different irrigation needs for greens, fairways, and roughs, while soccer or football fields need a durable turf that can withstand heavy foot traffic. The irrigation system must cater to these specific requirements to maintain optimal playing conditions.
  • Field Usage: The frequency and intensity of field use significantly impact the choice of an irrigation system. High-usage fields, such as those in professional stadiums, often require more robust and advanced irrigation systems that can recover quickly and maintain turf health despite heavy wear and tear. On the other hand, fields with less frequent use might opt for simpler, less expensive systems.
  • Environmental Conditions: Local climate and weather patterns are crucial in selecting an irrigation system. Areas with high rainfall might need less supplemental watering, whereas arid regions may require efficient and regular irrigation systems. Additionally, factors like wind patterns and sun exposure also influence the type of system and its setup.
  • Budget Constraints: The available budget can significantly limit or expand the options for an irrigation system. High-end collegiate stadiums might invest in sophisticated, automated systems with advanced features like moisture sensors and programmable watering schedules. In contrast, community sports fields or school facilities with limited budgets might prioritize cost-effective solutions, focusing on basic but reliable systems.

Get in Touch with a Professional Sports Field Irrigation Company

Early consultation with professional sports field irrigation companies is crucial for designing an effective and sustainable system. Experts offer valuable insights on soil, turf, and climate, helping avoid common problems like uneven watering and resource wastage. Their involvement can lead to a cost-effective, environmentally responsible system, preventing expensive future modifications.

Involving these professionals from the start also ensures operational efficiencies and compliance with local regulations. This foresight in planning and design is a wise investment, safeguarding the long-term quality and viability of the sports field.

Read more: Sports Field Irrigation Companies in the U.S. + The Top Five List

Conclusion

Selecting the right irrigation system for a sports field is a crucial decision that impacts the quality of play and overall experience. With technological advancements, the options for irrigation have grown, ranging from automated to manual systems, each offering precision and efficiency. For natural grass, the system must maintain turf health and suit local conditions, while conserving water and energy. For synthetic turf, the focus is on cooling and maintenance to enhance player comfort and extend turf longevity. Sustainable practices are essential, considering the environmental impact of irrigation. Ultimately, choosing an irrigation system requires a balance of technical knowledge and practical application, tailored to each field’s unique needs and evolving with technological progress. This choice is fundamental in maintaining high-quality sports facilities globally.

If you are currently planning to invest in a sports turf irrigation or sprinkler system, try our cost calculator to get a customized cost estimate for your needs.